In Avowed's "Fires in the Mine" side quest, the choice of supporting or stopping Darle might seem equally valid depending on your perspective. However, considering XP, gold, loot, and narrative impact, one choice clearly offers superior rewards.
For maximizing rewards in Avowed's "Fires in the Mine," preventing Darle from destroying the mine is the best option. While supporting Darle yields 1026 XP, stopping him offers significantly more overall.
Supporting Darle: The Consequences
Letting Darle blow up the mine nets you 1026 XP upon mission completion. However, you forfeit any monetary reward from Kada and Seyon, straining relations between the Aedyrans and Thirdborn. Attempts to lie about your actions won't change this outcome.
Stopping Darle: The Rewards
Stopping Darle yields 212 XP for the kill, plus 879 XP after debriefing—a total of 1091 XP, surpassing the reward for supporting him. You also receive 900 coins from Seyon and Kada. Looting Darle's corpse provides a Blackwood Branch (a superb upgrade material), Wild Mushroom Stew, Beetle Pie (x2). While the food is minor, the Blackwood Branch is a valuable addition.
Maintaining positive relations between the Thirdborn and Aedyrans is a narrative bonus. However, from a gameplay perspective, stopping Darle provides superior XP, gold, and loot.
Having made the optimal choice in "Fires in the Mine," consider exploring all 12 Treasure Map locations for exclusive gear. If you're focused on leveling up, find out the maximum level in Avowed to plan your character progression.
