Home News College or Pro: MLB The Show 25 Career Choice Guide

College or Pro: MLB The Show 25 Career Choice Guide

Author : Carter May 20,2025

*MLB The Show 25* has arrived, bringing with it a fresh iteration of the beloved Road to the Show mode, where players can live out their dreams of becoming a major league star. One of the first big decisions you'll face is whether to pursue a college education or jump straight into the pros. This choice sets the stage for your journey in *MLB The Show 25* Road to the Show.

Should You Choose College or the Big Leagues in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show?

Choosing between college and pros in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show.

In *MLB The Show 25*, you start your Road to the Show journey as a high school player with a pivotal decision to make. Scouts from top colleges and major league teams are vying for your talents, but you can only choose one path.

Your high school career culminates in a state title run, where scouts will evaluate your performance. Between games, you'll get insights into your future choices, including which teams are interested in drafting you. Your performance at the high school level and the MLB Combine will directly impact your draft stock and the number of colleges eager to recruit you.

After the MLB Combine, you'll commit to a school, and the draft will take place. Even if you plan to attend college, a professional team will draft you. This is when you make your final decision. *MLB The Show 25* clearly outlines your options, as seen in the choices provided to The Escapist after being drafted:

  • If I Go Pro:
    • Receive a signing bonus of 5 Tokens
    • Reduced chance of being fast-tracked to the Major Leagues
    • Begin pro career as an 18-year-old
  • If I Go To College:
    • Receive all benefits of LSU’s official offer
    • Pursue being the #1 overall pick in a future MLB Draft
    • Begin pro career as a 21-year-old after college career is completed

Ultimately, the decision hinges on your personal preferences. If you've spent previous seasons grinding through the minor leagues, the allure of college might be strong. The prestige of being the #1 overall pick and entering the pros as a more developed player can be incredibly rewarding. However, if you enjoy the challenge of starting from the bottom and working your way up, going pro straight out of high school might be more your style.

The Escapist opted for college, drawn by the chance to be the top draft pick and the appeal of a new experience. Plus, the game fast-forwards to your third year during a championship run, so you won't be away from professional baseball for long. This path allows you to enjoy the best of both worlds without a significant delay in your pro career.

So, whether you choose college or go pro in *MLB The Show 25* Road to the Show, it's all about what kind of journey you want to embark on. For more tips, check out the best pitching settings for the new sports game.

*MLB The Show 25 is now in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.*

Latest Articles More
  • Summoners War update adds formidable new monsters

    Summoners War: Sky Arena is introducing two new monstersA five-star Arcane Weapon and a four-star Centaur Knight join the battlePlayers can also look forward to special growth events and visual revamps for several monstersCom2Us's popular action RPG,

    Feb 23,2026
  • Closed Beta 2 for Where Winds Meet Opens in Select Regions

    Second Closed Beta sign-ups available until May 15thCBT launches May 16th with multilingual supportGame scheduled for full release later this yearFollowing our initial preview of this open-world action RPG last winter, Everstone Studio has officially

    Feb 22,2026
  • PolyFootball brings super-straightforward low-poly sports action to iOS, coming soon

    PolyFootball is the newest entry into the world of sports simulation. Take on a classic management experience with a fresh, graphical twist. Enjoy clean, intuitive sports simulation on iOS. It’s worth noting that after years of sports simulators pus

    Feb 21,2026
  • Jump King Expands Globally with Mobile Release, Expansions

    Jump King, the notoriously challenging 2D platformer that has tested gamers' patience worldwide, has officially launched on mobile devices. After a limited regional testing phase, Nexile and UKIYO Publishing have released the game globally for both A

    Feb 20,2026
  • Koizumi Pitched 3D Donkey Kong to Mario Odyssey Team

    When Donkey Kong Bananza was first announced, many speculated that it was being developed by the same team behind Super Mario Odyssey. That assumption proved correct, leading to further rumors that the game initially started as downloadable content o

    Feb 19,2026
  • Summoners War 2025 Championship Kicks Off in Paris

    The SWC2025 season is now officially underwayThe preliminary stage will take place throughout July and AugustThe finals are scheduled for November 1st in ParisSummoners War has returned to the global esports scene with its ninth annual World Arena Ch

    Feb 18,2026